Anglo-Spanish Relations
in the New World
Cologne War · Drake & Hawkins · The Armada · War of Spanish Succession · The Ugly Truths
When the Holy Roman Empire was a fragmented collection of largely independent states, titular Holy Roman Emperors from the House of Habsburg directly ruled large portions of Imperial territory, one dynasty ending with Elizabeth I of England. The House of Habsburg, also ruled Spain, including the Spanish Netherlands, southern Italy, the Philippines, and most of the Americas.
In the Cologne War 1583–88 amid a Protestant Reformation in Germany and its subsequent Counter-Reformation, (and concurrently with the Dutch Revolt and the French Wars of Religion), when Catholics sought peace, Spanish troops acted by expelling a Prince Archbishop and replacing him with a Roman Catholic. After this success, the principle of cuius regio, eius religio began to be exerted strictly forcing Protestant-Lutheran residents to choose between conversion or exile (Martin Luther's initial agenda called for the reform of the Church's doctrines and practices, but invoked his excommunication from the Church).
Much to the consternation of their Spanish ruling cousins, the Habsburg emperors who followed Charles V (especially Ferdinand I and Maximilian II, but also Rudolf II, and his successor Matthias) were content to allow the princes of the empire to choose their own religious policies. These rulers avoided religious wars within the empire by allowing the different Christian faiths to spread without coercion. This however angered those who sought religious uniformity such as the Protestant Union or the Catholic League, who together were merely sympathetic of the increasingly intolerant behavior towards others personal religious/political beliefs.
Drake, Hawkins & the Privateer WarThe ports of modern day Belgium, were notorious Privateer bases, plaguing the English fleets, and a Anglo-Spanish War had commenced in 1585 with England joining the Eighty Years' War on the side of the Dutch Protestant United Provinces, who had declared their independence from Spain. Sparing the long sown religious disturbances to Protestantism by Catholic Spain, Sir Frances Drake sailed for the West Indies to sack Santo Domingo, and additionally capture Cartagena de Indias, and St. Augustine in Florida.
As relations with Elizabeth I of England had begun to deteriorate prior, particularly after a restoration of Royal supremacy over the Church of England through the Act of Supremacy in 1559 (the Act was considered by Catholics as an usurpation of Papal authority and some English Protestants championed the Dutch Protestant 'rebels' directly against Spain); Sir John Hawkins, (who gained accreditation from Elizabeth I while the Spanish government complained that Hawkins' trade with their colonies in the West Indies constituted smuggling) fought the Spanish in September 1568, at the Battle of San Juan de Ulúa near Veracruz Mexico. Occurring when a slaving expedition led by Sir Francis Drake and Sir Hawkins met a surprise attacked by the Spanish, and several ships were captured or sunk. The battle soured Anglo-Spanish relations badly and in the following year the English detained several treasure ships sent by the Spanish to supply their army in the Netherlands. Drakes (and Hawkins) intensified 'privateering' continued as a way to break the Spanish monopoly on Atlantic trade.
The Spanish ArmadaThe English hit back in Galicia (north of Portugal) and sacked Vigo and Baiona, when Philip II planned a full invasion in retaliation. In the same year, the execution of Mary, Queen of Scots had outraged Catholics in Europe, and her claim on the English throne passed over (by her own deed of will) to Philip. Philip II obtained Papal authority to overthrow Elizabeth hence, who was excommunicated by Pope Pius V, and he was granted power to place whomever he chose on the throne of England. Mary who was raised in France and bore James I, had been found guilty of plotting to kill Elizabeth.
Philip assembled a fleet of about 130 ships, containing 8,000 soldiers and 18,000 sailors. Pope Sixtus V had permitted Philip to collect crusade taxes for their holy cause, and promised a further subsidy should they actually reach England.
Philip assembled a fleet of about 130 ships, containing 8,000 soldiers and 18,000 sailors. To finance this endeavor, Pope Sixtus V had permitted Philip to collect crusade taxes for their holy cause, and promised a further subsidy too should they actually reach England. On 28 May 1588, the Armada set sail for the Netherlands, where it was to pick up additional troops for the invasion of England. However, the English navy inflicted a defeat on the Armada in the Battle of Gravelines before this could be accomplished, and forced the Armada to sail far northward where it was ruined by weather.
Meanwhile across the Atlantic both Drake and Hawkins would die of disease during the disastrous 1595–96 expedition against Puerto Rico, Panama, and other targets in the Spanish Main. Continuing conflicts occurred in 1595, when a Spanish force, under Don Carlos de Amesquita raided Penzance and several surrounding villages. Then in 1596 an Anglo-Dutch expedition under Elizabeth's earl of Essex, sacked Cadiz, causing significant loss to the Spanish fleet, leaving the city in ruins. Despite English failure to capture a treasure fleet, the sack of Cadiz was celebrated as a national triumph comparable to an absolute victory.
James I would declare war on Spain likewise and with the support of the House of Commons, attempt to cripple Spanish investiture by obtaining the sizeable seizures from the Inca, and Aztecan civilisation's (attributions of the Papacies missions with indigenous were scantly welcomed such as Father Ximénezs contributions of the Chilam Balam and Popul Vuh)
With the signing of the Triple Alliance in 1596 between France, England and the Dutch, Elizabeth sent a further 2,000 troops into France after the Spanish invaded Calais in support. For another two years the battles continued until Henry IV's conversion to Catholicism had won him widespread French support and the French civil war turned against the hardliners of the Catholic League. With France and Spain's signing of the Peace of Vervins, the War of Religions particular factional disputes between the aristocratic houses, such as the House of Bourbon and House of Guise (Lorraine) ceased.
The End of the Habsburg Kings of Spain — & Juana la LocaThe War of the Spanish Succession would see the end of the Habsburg Kings of Spain 1516–1700. The conflict was triggered by the death in 1700 of the Spanish King (childless) Charles II, resulting in the Spanish empires partitioning between major and minor powers. The Austrians received most of Spain's former European realms, but peninsular Spain and Spanish America were retained for the Duke of Anjou when, after renouncing his claim to the French succession, he reigned as King Philip V. Charles II had had neither a pleasant life nor a successful reign. He was physically disabled, mentally retarded and disfigured, impotent, and he died senile and wracked by epileptic seizures, a fitting end only to a line with 16 generations of inbreeding. The Spanish Habsburg dynasty had started with the marriage between Philip I, also known as Philip the Fair, and Joanna I, also known as Joanna the Mad.
Joanna of Castile was the daughter of Ferdinand and Isabella — the same monarchs who sponsored Columbus and expelled the Jews from Spain. She was sister to Catherine of Aragon (the first wife of Henry VIII) and, through her marriage to Philip the Fair of Austria, became the linchpin of the Habsburg dynasty that would dominate Europe for two centuries. She never ruled.
Her so-called madness — the label that kept her imprisoned in Tordesillas castle for 46 years — was convenient to three successive men: her husband Philip, who needed her politically pliant; her father Ferdinand, who wanted regency over Castile; and her son Charles V, who wanted an uncontested throne. Modern historians and psychiatrists have suggested her symptoms were consistent with severe depression, melancholia, or grief psychosis — triggered above all by Philip's relentless infidelities. Her 'madness' was her refusal to cooperate.
The story most often told — that she travelled with Philip's corpse after his death in 1506, opening the coffin at intervals to prevent women from touching the body — is almost certainly a political fabrication, or at minimum a grotesque exaggeration of grief weaponised against her. Francisco Pradilla's 1877 painting Doña Juana la Loca in the Prado is the most famous visual record of how history chose to remember her: a woman in black, anchoring a desolate landscape, with the coffin. The painting is magnificent and almost certainly dishonest. She died in 1555, still imprisoned, having outlived her son's entire first decade of reign.
The dynasty she inadvertently founded ended with Charles II — so comprehensively destroyed by the inbreeding she set in motion that he could barely function. The line began with a woman who was arguably saner than the men who imprisoned her, and ended with a man who was arguably not sane at all.
The definitive English-language scholarly biography. Aram draws on fresh archival research to argue that Juana employed deliberate pious resistance — not madness — to defend her sovereignty. The Times Literary Supplement noted: "madness, like gender, proved a flexible concept in the realm of sovereignty." Indispensable for anyone who wants to understand what was actually at stake in Tordesillas.
A popular historical novel that takes Juana's perspective seriously — the account of a woman facing "relentless physical and mental cruelty" from Philip, Ferdinand, and Charles with "courage and determination." Historically grounded and readable for a non-specialist audience. The novel most often recommended for readers coming to the story for the first time.
A clinical reassessment of the historical psychiatric record. Modern analysis suggests severe depression, melancholia, and possible psychosis — none of which would have justified 46 years of imprisonment under contemporary standards. Useful for understanding how the diagnosis was weaponised.
An older popular biography, sympathetic and somewhat romanticised, but still widely read and an accessible starting point. Places Juana in the full sweep of the Spanish succession crisis.
The authoritative account of Philip II's imperial project — the strategic logic behind the Armada, the Dutch war, and the broader contest with England. Parker makes the case that Philip was not the blundering fanatic of Protestant legend but a systematic, if ultimately overextended, imperial strategist.
A revisionist biography that strips the legend from Drake and examines the man as Elizabeth's instrument of plausible deniability — simultaneously privateer, naval commander, and political liability. Kelsey is unsentimental about Drake's slaving expeditions and their role in provoking the Armada.
Written by Jason Steven Jowett. Sourced from historical fact. This blog may not be reproduced in whole without the author's express permission. Copyright © 2024. greatbrittania.blogspot.com